, ,

Jess Weiner & Eating Disorders

Oh the hoopla over Jess Weiner’s article in Glamour Magazine, “Did Loving My Body Almost Kill Me?” going to a doctor, finding out that she’s 250 pounds, pre-diabetic and her cholesterol sucked and then having the audacity to do something about it.

This, from the woman who wrote Life Doesn’t Begin Five Pounds From Now .

I’ve read countless articles both defending and attacking Jess for admitting that she was glad to have lost 25 pounds and – how dare she – admit to having a goal to lose 25 more.

Because there’s this whole new school of thought that you can be Healthy at Every Size and Jess was kind of their role model, their ring leader, their thought leader. There’s a bunch of websites and books about Healthy at Any Weight. They claim that all the science that claim the correlation between obesity and being overweight and heart disease, diabetes, infertility, depression, stroke and a whole host of other deadly illnesses can’t be proven and aren’t really fat-related at all. It’s just a conspiracy against fat people – a social conspiracy. Because we don’t like them. It’s discrimination in the disguise of science.

A lot of really nice, awesome people that I actually respect and admire sit in this Healthy At Every Size camp, so I have pretty much shut my mouth about it. Except I don’t buy it. And I think it sets a lot of people up for a lot of very serious health risks, deadly ones.

I’ve read a lot of misinformation and a lot of well, weird theories about how Jess’s diet, and her new venture in conscious weight loss, is going to cost a lot of girls with eating disorders their recovery and may even cost them their lives.

I think that’s backasswards. It doesn’t make any sense at all.

Did loving her body almost kill Jess Weiner? In a word, No. Because loving your body involves taking care of it, which means it doesn’t get to be 250 pounds. Because you take it to the gym and you make it sweat. You read labels and watch what you put into it.

And on many of these eating disorder recovery blogs I’ve read that they are worried that Jess may be “falling back into her former eating disorder” by deciding she needs to shed a few pounds.

Here’s the flaw with that theory: There is more than one type of eating disorder. Sure there is bulimia and anorexia. But there is also obesity and unconscious eating and eating to stuff one’s feelings, which IS an eating disorder. It is extremely common for people with addictions and eating disorders to simply switch one to another. Which is why you have very high rates of people who have gastric bypass surgery fall into alcoholism – they didn’t recover – they switched their addictions. Or coke heads who quit doing cocaine only to pick up alcohol. Did Jess really recover from her eating disorder? Or did she go from one eating disorder to another one and hide behind a Healthy At Any Size movement that makes it super easy to hide what appears to be a more socially acceptable eating disorder according to the moralistic tone in which it’s prophets deliver it’s message? Only Jess can answer that. Probably, it’s just another step in her path to recovery.

Can you be Healthy At Every Size or Healthy At Any Weight?

No, You Can’t.

A person cannot sustain a body that is 300 or 400 or 500  pounds and not suffer the consequences of impaired mobility, restricted lifestyle, high blood pressure, bad cholesterol, painful joints, diabetes, heart disease or any number of health risks.

Should we treat people at every size and every weight with love and respect? Absolutely. But that’s another issue entirely. Entertaining fictions that could kill them, or at the very least, harm them isn’t a loving act though is it?

Should girls be pressured into a narrow beauty ideal depicted in media and marketing? Absolutely not.

But, the alternative to that is not to be complacent about obesity and overeating.

I recently saw the statistic that 7 million girls suffer from eating disorders. I take issue with that.

Those numbers do not take into account the one in three (1 in 3!) children in this country who are overweight or obese, suffering from the other eating disorders of overeating, medicating themselves with food, unconscious eating, etc. Food is their first drug of choice, the first drug they have access too. And it baffles me why some child advocates, eating disorder organizations, educators and parents aren’t more concerned with those numbers and tend to focus only on the much smaller population of kids who prefer to starve themselves.

Help me change my life?  Tracee Sioux can assist you.  Subscribe to her newsletter to find out how.

142 replies
  1. Arianne May says:

    If every one could be healthy at any size, will we don’t need a doctor or something anymore. I cant believe it.

  2. meneligirl says:

    There are more issues to be concerned about than this. There is the onset of early diabetes on kids. Though the main post talks about issues relating to none eating disorder, I think that is not too serious to be focused on right now.

  3. Claudia says:

    You are very right and bring up a really good point. We should be more concerned with child obesity and also obesity in general. Why focus all our energy on revealing other people’s bad lifestyle habits when there are tons of other people who need our attention more than they do. Eating disorders are definitely not as important, in my eyes, as the subject of obesity, but both topics do require some amount of attention.

  4. Ryu says:

    That question’s answer is really too simple. Of course, you can’t be healthy with any size or weight. If that were the case, there would be no need to go on a proper diet and balanced meal.

  5. SonjaSig says:

    best cbd oil online cbd oil capsules 25 mg cbd oil benefits and side effects – cbdhempoilsale.us
    cbd oil online cannabis oil capsules for sale cbd oil for dogs with separation anxiety – https://cbdhempoilsale.us

    best cbd oil for bone cancer pain – https://cbdhempoilsale.us cbd oil benefits uses – cbdhempoilsale.us cbd oil for pain for sale – https://cbdhempoilsale.us
    side effects of cbd oil in dogs – cbdhempoilsale.us pure cannabis oil for sale cbd oil for pain through amazon – cbdhempoilsale.us

  6. Alyonatit says:

    viagra golden root shops|prijzen viagra|brand viagra professional|free viagra samples by mail|get viagra yahoo|indian version of viagra|better cialis viagra levitra|viagra wirkungsweise|viagra ecstasy tablets pills|viagra ou generiqu|purchasing viagra online|viagra costs walgreens|much prescription viagra uk|viagra womens buy|how to buy brand viagra online|phuket viagra prices|cheap uk viagra prices|buy discounted viagra softtabs|viagra e bstorebiz|effetto viagra 25 mg|tomar viagra es malo|viagra salud mental|blogs best viagra tab|viagra for altitude sickness|price of viagra in mumbai|cost of viagra in saudi arabia|recommended site viagra 20 mg|buy viagra online in praha|viagra ad|look here viagra cost|try it online viagra in 24h|good choice viagra injectable|vente viagra prix discount|viagra prescription mdical|is it ok to buy viagra|achat de viagra sans ordonnanc|viagra bestellen aus polen|viagra 50mg generic|buy viagra super plus|viagra offshore|le viagra 5|viagra song download|can you take viagra across|viagra super active plus|pfizer viagra wholesale|valium viagra online|hvor kan jeg bestille viagra|viagra online in europe|viagra for the brain 20 20|order viagra india|cost of brand viagra online|viagra nebenwirkungen sanego|discount generic viagra panama|viagra naturel net|viagra pills expire|looking generic viagra|buy female viagra discount|viagra vademecum precio|viagra delivery to us idaho|viagra and cialis canada|buying viagra online in india|costo del viagra slovenia|viagra vente libre france|cost of viagra cialis|generic viagra us customs|buy australian viagra|herb viagra 6800mg|viagra barata espaa|viagra pill 50mg price|viagra softonline usa|where get viagra online cheap|brand viagra echeck|viagra hombres para mujere|cialis inde de viagra|venta de viagra zona sur|viagra prescription canada no|viagra pfizer webcindario co|with viagra i can buy|viagra online fedex|venta viagra barata|farmacia del canada viagra|washington post viagra|buy female viagra online cheap|viagra mail order australia|where to by viagra in canada|viagra cialis o levitra|viagra homme prix|get viagra samples|female viagra sale uk|achat viagra marseille|online buy viagra|order canadian viagra online|want to buy viagra|viagra online prices za|online viagra sales best place|wow look it purchase of viagra|viagra t shirt|buy viagra from amazon|where can i get viagra samples|viagra swallow whole or split|purchase viagra delhi chemist|very good site women viagra|viagra bestellen preis|viagra pro sconto|cheap buy viagra uk|2010 price in viagra|viagra review best|prescription price viagra|viagra price in oman|will viagra generic|viagra jeune ag|viagra tablets price rupees|how i do viagra australia buy|viagra aurochem|can you take viagra with xanax|discount generic viagra usa rx|canadian wholesale viagra|can anxiety person take viagra|viagra source or reputable|wirkung von viagra erfahrungen|viagra bremen|generic viagra is safe|viagra symptoms|buy viagra super active plus|order viagra online legal|mouse found viagra|viagra se vende libre|can diabetic take viagra|viagra achat singapourien|viagra et similaire|viagra positioning|online viagra sales cipla|cvs pharmacy generic viagra|buy generic viagra 50mg online|cost viagra indian market|online chat viagra|viagra rezeptfrei|viagra segura online|viagra kaufen bankeinzug|viagra cost 100mg|take viagra with afib|viagra selling in singapore|generic viagra sale in canada|kaufen viagra rezeptfre|buy in real viagra|expired viagra cialis levitra|cheap brand viagra sale uk|viagra o alternativi|vente libre de viagra|to cheap online where viagra|viagra et sante|express script viagra price|viagra et la sant|farmacia canadiense viagra|vendo viagra en venta|can i take 2 viagra tablets|preiswerte viagra pille online|good generic viagra|generic viagra canada customs|walgreensand generic viagra|viagra dose minima|order viagra pill|can take how often viagra|viagra histoir|buy viagra men women|viagra online mexican pharmacy|viagra 40 for 99|buy viagra prices pharmacy|precio barato para viagra|wo gibts viagra zu kaufen|we choice best viagra online|generic viagra secure tabs|can i get viagra|cash price viagra|we recommend viagra 20 mg|online viagra prices|viagra and male orgazum|il viagra cost|viagra generic online usa|viagra nz website|viagra bestellen mit rezept|viagra come acquistare|recommended site viagra 30 mg|viagra europa kaufen|larginine viagra interaction|what all does viagra treat|precio viagra receta|viagra experience|viagra 75 m|viagra canada reviews|viagra side affects|were you buy liquid viagra|generic viagra pfizer viagra|safe take generic viagra|viagra generika preisvergleich|viagra symbol|cheap 150 mg viagra|viagra rebajada|i recommend viagra seizures|look here viagra 25mg|get viagra from india|viagra et autres|generic viagra coming us|an alternative to viagra|viagra his and hers combo pack|descuentos en cupones viagra|amyl nitrate erection viagra|what is brand viagra made of|recommended site viagra jelly|only here viagra woman|viagra cialis levitra effects|viagra cialis for sale uk|nombre viagra genericos|age most men take viagra|super viagra active|comment acheter viagra maroc|quality of indian viagra|viagra lontano dai pasti|ciscount viagra|what does a viagra look like|acheter viagra en france forum|viagra europ|viagra pille frau|prices of viagra online|can you buy viagra in japan|canadian dosage viagra|viagra golf|viagra stock value|the best site viagra cost|golden rx cheap viagra|sconto in linea viagra|viagra american express canada|viagra indian pharmacy|kamagra viagra online|farmacias irlandesas viagra|use of female viagra|very good site 100 mg viagra|very good site viagra purchase|viagra from pfizer online|viagra sin receta en espaa|50 mg viagra vs 100 mg|viagra order in nz|we use it viagra prices in usa|viagra generico para mujer|female viagra 100mg|cialis wirkt nicht viagra|buying viagra us online|viagra zihuatanejo|lowest price on viagra|meilleures sites achats viagra

    http://viagrarwiuuy.com/ – buy viagra online
    online viagra

    viagra golden root shops|prijzen viagra|brand viagra professional|free viagra samples by mail|get viagra yahoo|indian version of viagra|better cialis viagra levitra|viagra wirkungsweise|viagra ecstasy tablets pills|viagra ou generiqu|purchasing viagra online|viagra costs walgreens|much prescription viagra uk|viagra womens buy|how to buy brand viagra online|phuket viagra prices|cheap uk viagra prices|buy discounted viagra softtabs|viagra e bstorebiz|effetto viagra 25 mg|tomar viagra es malo|viagra salud mental|blogs best viagra tab|viagra for altitude sickness|price of viagra in mumbai|cost of viagra in saudi arabia|recommended site viagra 20 mg|buy viagra online in praha|viagra ad|look here viagra cost|try it online viagra in 24h|good choice viagra injectable|vente viagra prix discount|viagra prescription mdical|is it ok to buy viagra|achat de viagra sans ordonnanc|viagra bestellen aus polen|viagra 50mg generic|buy viagra super plus|viagra offshore|le viagra 5|viagra song download|can you take viagra across|viagra super active plus|pfizer viagra wholesale|valium viagra online|hvor kan jeg bestille viagra|viagra online in europe|viagra for the brain 20 20|order viagra india|cost of brand viagra online|viagra nebenwirkungen sanego|discount generic viagra panama|viagra naturel net|viagra pills expire|looking generic viagra|buy female viagra discount|viagra vademecum precio|viagra delivery to us idaho|viagra and cialis canada|buying viagra online in india|costo del viagra slovenia|viagra vente libre france|cost of viagra cialis|generic viagra us customs|buy australian viagra|herb viagra 6800mg|viagra barata espaa|viagra pill 50mg price|viagra softonline usa|where get viagra online cheap|brand viagra echeck|viagra hombres para mujere|cialis inde de viagra|venta de viagra zona sur|viagra prescription canada no|viagra pfizer webcindario co|with viagra i can buy|viagra online fedex|venta viagra barata|farmacia del canada viagra|washington post viagra|buy female viagra online cheap|viagra mail order australia|where to by viagra in canada|viagra cialis o levitra|viagra homme prix|get viagra samples|female viagra sale uk|achat viagra marseille|online buy viagra|order canadian viagra online|want to buy viagra|viagra online prices za|online viagra sales best place|wow look it purchase of viagra|viagra t shirt|buy viagra from amazon|where can i get viagra samples|viagra swallow whole or split|purchase viagra delhi chemist|very good site women viagra|viagra bestellen preis|viagra pro sconto|cheap buy viagra uk|2010 price in viagra|viagra review best|prescription price viagra|viagra price in oman|will viagra generic|viagra jeune ag|viagra tablets price rupees|how i do viagra australia buy|viagra aurochem|can you take viagra with xanax|discount generic viagra usa rx|canadian wholesale viagra|can anxiety person take viagra|viagra source or reputable|wirkung von viagra erfahrungen|viagra bremen|generic viagra is safe|viagra symptoms|buy viagra super active plus|order viagra online legal|mouse found viagra|viagra se vende libre|can diabetic take viagra|viagra achat singapourien|viagra et similaire|viagra positioning|online viagra sales cipla|cvs pharmacy generic viagra|buy generic viagra 50mg online|cost viagra indian market|online chat viagra|viagra rezeptfrei|viagra segura online|viagra kaufen bankeinzug|viagra cost 100mg|take viagra with afib|viagra selling in singapore|generic viagra sale in canada|kaufen viagra rezeptfre|buy in real viagra|expired viagra cialis levitra|cheap brand viagra sale uk|viagra o alternativi|vente libre de viagra|to cheap online where viagra|viagra et sante|express script viagra price|viagra et la sant|farmacia canadiense viagra|vendo viagra en venta|can i take 2 viagra tablets|preiswerte viagra pille online|good generic viagra|generic viagra canada customs|walgreensand generic viagra|viagra dose minima|order viagra pill|can take how often viagra|viagra histoir|buy viagra men women|viagra online mexican pharmacy|viagra 40 for 99|buy viagra prices pharmacy|precio barato para viagra|wo gibts viagra zu kaufen|we choice best viagra online|generic viagra secure tabs|can i get viagra|cash price viagra|we recommend viagra 20 mg|online viagra prices|viagra and male orgazum|il viagra cost|viagra generic online usa|viagra nz website|viagra bestellen mit rezept|viagra come acquistare|recommended site viagra 30 mg|viagra europa kaufen|larginine viagra interaction|what all does viagra treat|precio viagra receta|viagra experience|viagra 75 m|viagra canada reviews|viagra side affects|were you buy liquid viagra|generic viagra pfizer viagra|safe take generic viagra|viagra generika preisvergleich|viagra symbol|cheap 150 mg viagra|viagra rebajada|i recommend viagra seizures|look here viagra 25mg|get viagra from india|viagra et autres|generic viagra coming us|an alternative to viagra|viagra his and hers combo pack|descuentos en cupones viagra|amyl nitrate erection viagra|what is brand viagra made of|recommended site viagra jelly|only here viagra woman|viagra cialis levitra effects|viagra cialis for sale uk|nombre viagra genericos|age most men take viagra|super viagra active|comment acheter viagra maroc|quality of indian viagra|viagra lontano dai pasti|ciscount viagra|what does a viagra look like|acheter viagra en france forum|viagra europ|viagra pille frau|prices of viagra online|can you buy viagra in japan|canadian dosage viagra|viagra golf|viagra stock value|the best site viagra cost|golden rx cheap viagra|sconto in linea viagra|viagra american express canada|viagra indian pharmacy|kamagra viagra online|farmacias irlandesas viagra|use of female viagra|very good site 100 mg viagra|very good site viagra purchase|viagra from pfizer online|viagra sin receta en espaa|50 mg viagra vs 100 mg|viagra order in nz|we use it viagra prices in usa|viagra generico para mujer|female viagra 100mg|cialis wirkt nicht viagra|buying viagra us online|viagra zihuatanejo|lowest price on viagra|meilleures sites achats viagra

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. […] this year I wrote a post about Jess Weiner’s body issues. I feel bad about it. I want to apologize and make amends. Jess Weiner’s body […]

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.